How to Make Yorkshire Puddings

Yorkshire Pudding

A few weeks ago I asked Facebook for some help due to the fact that I always have Yorkshire Pudding fail – you came up with recipes and tips by the bucket load and in response I bored you to tears with photos of each batch I created.  Thank you to all of you who helped me out with your top tips and recipes – I’m pleased to say my Sunday roasts are now complete!

Yesterday was National Yorkshire Pudding Day and although I’m a day late I thought it was time for me to share my new found Yorkshire Pudding skills!

My top tip is to persevere, I have spent years unable to make Yorkshire Puds and have always resorted to Aunt Bessies, not any more.  If you have Yorkie Pud demons its time to tackle them head on!


125g plain flour

2 eggs, large

200ml milk

Salt and pepper

Trex/Lard/Vegetable Oil

Makes 12.

You need a deep 12-hole tin. I’ve sacrificed a cupcake tin for the purpose.

jan proj3 039

Make up the batter, I like to make it in a jug rather than a bowl then its ready for pouring into the tin (and saves on washing up!)

Place the flour in the base and crack in 2 large eggs.


Start to whisk the eggs, incorporating a little of the flour as you do so.


Keep whisking, adding in a little of the milk at a time and working in more of the flour until all the milk has been added and all of the flour is incorporated.  The batter should be the consistency of single cream.

DSC06190 DSC06192

I’d like to say a Pink Whisk makes all the difference, it doesn’t but it does make me smile!

Now set the batter to one side whilst we get on with the rest…

Preheat the oven to 220c (fan)/240c/Gas Mark 9. – This is important, if you’re oven isn’t hot enough you’ll have pancakes.

Once the oven is preheated add a little oil to each recess of the tin, either half a teaspoon of vegetable or sunflower oil or a 1/2 cm square piece of Trex or Lard.


Bob the tray in the oven on a shelf in the top part of the oven for 10-15 minutes to heat up the oil,  it needs to be sizzling hot.

Before you take it out to add the batter, first add a good pinch of salt and pepper to the pudding batter and give it a final whisk.


Tray out of the oven and without hanging about pour the batter into each recess,  I count 1…2… while filling each.  But they should be about half full – 1.5cm deep.



You will see that the hot oil has already started to sizzle the outsides of each pud.


Still no hanging around – straight back into the top of the oven and set the timer for 16 minutes.

No peeking, I know you’re dying to!  If you can’t wait then you can open the oven door and peek after 12 mins, any earlier and they’ll most likely collapse!

After 16 mins baking check that the bottoms are cooked through – occasionally they’ll need another 2 mins just to bake the bases through fully.


If you follow the instructions you’ll have Yorkshire Puds that rise 5cm out of the top of the tin, beautifully risen and hollow inside (important for filling with gravy).


The odd one will be wonky but hey for rejects they still taste darn good!


Either serve them right away, or transfer them to a wire rack to cool completely (this stops them sweating in the tin and going soggy) you can either freeze them right away once they’ve cooled or reheat them for a 2-3 minutes in a hot oven to serve with your roast.

Now then,  if you want to make a big one to fight over tear and share I’ve found it’s better to have the batter much thicker (thank you to Claire @aceofcakes18 on twitter for this tip off) – make it as before but just use 125ml of milk so the batter is the consistency of double cream.  Same rules apply, enough oil to fill the base heated till smoking hot, batter in and back in the oven without hanging around.  Bake it for 22 minutes before serving right away. I have a 16cm square pyrex dish that is just the perfect size.

feb projects1 003 DSC06305

Look at this trying to climb out of the dish!


Top tips for Yorkshire Pudding Success:

Hot hot hot oven – not hot enough and you’ll have pancakes

Enough oil/lard etc in the base, not enough and the blighters will need chiselling out!

Preheat the oil in the tin long enough to be smoking hot before adding the batter.

Batter should go into the tin and the tin back into the oven pretty sharpish.

Don’t open the oven door to have a peek until after three quarters of the baking time has passed or they’ll collapse!

I still haven’t cracked the perfect batter recipe for Toad in the Hole or for making shallow Yorkshire puds, but hey who needs these when we have perfect puds for dowsing in gravy (plus the boys have pleaded with me, no more for now!)


How to Make Yorkshire Puddings

Ruth Clemens, Baker Extraordinaire

Meet me down the aisles of The Pink Whisk Shop – for all sorts of cake decorating and baking delights!



Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Print Friendly, PDF & Email
This entry was posted in How To, Savoury. Bookmark the permalink.

19 Responses to How to Make Yorkshire Puddings

  1. Diane says:

    Thanks a million for this recipe. I too am having loads of trouble with toad in the hole. No matter what i do it comes out stodgy and flat. Might just cook the sausages separately and make these to go with it.

  2. Kat says:

    Toad in the hole: Add oil to bottom or large dish and heat in the oven (as per normal yorkshire puds), add chopped onion and cook for 5 mins (or until soft), add cooked sausages and yorkshire pudding batter that has a little cold water in to thin the mixture slightly, and cook for 30 – 40 minutes. Amount of mixture dependent on how large a dish you are making. I usually use 8 sausages and a 3 egg yorkshire pudding batter, and that serves 3 with leftovers for lunch the next day x

  3. Lucy says:

    Am sitting here eating my healthy granola from your recipe – you are right, it is a winner, and now my health kick has taken a tumble already – how can I resist trying out the Yorkies recipe?!!!!

  4. diane hibble says:

    AAAhhhh….. The fog clears !
    Thank you Ruth. I’m a yorkie failure up to now also (1 batch in about 10 worked !!)

    I never knew the amounts changed depending on large or small or toad in the hole !! I do now !

  5. Dawn says:

    I have tried and tried too and wanted To ask what milk are you using.i wondered if my problem s I only ave semi skimmed in. what do you think

  6. dharma says:

    Fantastic recipe, bravo, I’ve always found very difficult to do.


  7. Laura Dodson says:

    Fab – thanks for this as I too struggle with this classic. Can’t wait to try it out. Mine always get stuck to the tin and fail to rise. Have you tried Toad in the Hole yet? Another one that fails for me. Laura

  8. Dawn says:

    These look lovely. I make all of my Yorkshire in the same way, in a jug, never weight the ingredients, mix with a fork thinking only nice thoughts. This is the recipe my dad taught me when I was about 12 and I have used it ever since. They never fail

  9. Claire says:

    Have never been able to make Yorkshire puds, always resorted to Aunt Bessie but even I could make these! Brilliant recipe.

  10. Hollyhothair says:

    Hiya, so you heat oven on high and keep on high once you put them in???

  11. Naomi Mizen says:

    I had previously had a problem and unable to make light and big yorkshires….. Praise to The Pink Whisk after following your instructions my Yorkshire puddings were fabulous. The family wished there were more than 12! Thank you 🙂

  12. Amanda Scott says:

    New fail safe recipe – they have been perfect every time – thanks Ruth x

  13. clare says:

    Every time i take my yorkshires out of oven they seem to lose there rise.dont know how to keep them risen?

  14. Pingback: Tree Classics Holiday Guide: Wonderful Christmas Party Idas | Tree Classics Blog - Artificial Tree Inspiration and Know How

  15. sarah says:

    Best recipe so far! 12 perfect yorkshires for the first time ever. Shall definately be using this again!

  16. Pingback: yorkshire pudding recipe to make 12 | Recipe Unique

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *