Banoffee Pie

Jan 14 100

This was the birthday bake of request from my youngest, Fin, just recently. Lots of you asked for the recipe so of course here it is.  Whilst not strictly baking, I’m sure you’ll forgive me! I’m including instructions to make the toffee layer from sugar/butter and cream so you don’t have to use condensed milk if you don’t want to.  It’s always good to learn something new.



250g digestive biscuits

100g butter, melted

Toffee Layer (3 options depending on how much time or bother you want to go to!)

Option 1. 1 x 397g can of ready made Carnation Caramel

Option 2. 1 x 397g can of condensed milk

Option 3.

140g caster sugar

50g light muscovado sugar

90g golden syrup

200ml double cream

50g butter, diced and softened

1 tsp vanilla extract

1/2 tsp salt


1 1/2 – 2 bananas

200ml double cream

2 tbsps icing sugar

chocolate shavings to decorate

Makes 1 x 8″ Pie

So to start with the tin and the crust.  I use an 8″ pushpan from Lakeland now instead of springform tins for all my cheesecakes, pies etc.  I’ve long disliked the ridges in the base/side of springform tins and find that they trap whatever you’re baking into them.  The pushpans are very good and have completely flat sides and base, not that I want the blame for encouraging you to the Lakeland website but…. here’s the link 😉 Lakeland Push Pans

Grease the tin  lightly and crush the digestive biscuits, food processor is the easiest option but a bag and a bash with the rolling pin will work just as well.

Jan 14 042

In a big-ish bowl mix the digestive crumbs with the melted butter to make a sandy mixture.

Jan 14 043

Tip them into the tin and work on the sides first, a silicone spatula works well to press it up against the sides, compacting the crumbs working to roughly the same height and thickness of crust, don’t worry about the base for now.

Jan 14 045

Level off the crust on the top edge pressing it down.

Jan 14 046

Now for the base, spread out the remaining crumbs and press down well making sure to join the base to the sides.

Jan 14 047

Put it in the fridge for at least 1 hour to chill.

Now for the toffee you can of course use a can of ready made caramel (in which case just empty it in), or you can use a tin of condensed milk.


So to convert your can of condensed milk to caramel – Place it in a large pan, unopened and cover completely with water.  (Adding 1 tbsp of vinegar to the water will help stop the pan being marked by limescale)


Bring the water to the boil, reduce the heat and simmer for 1 hour 30 minutes, regularly topping up the water.

Turn off the heat and leave the tin in the pan of water to cool completely, ideally overnight. Once fully cooled the tin can be opened to reveal a lovely caramel for you to use.


If you want to make your own toffee in a pan it’s easy to do, a sugar thermometer is extremely useful but it can be done without it.

Put the caster, muscovado sugar and golden syrup in a medium sized pan.

Jan 14 019

Heat is gently, gently until the sugar has dissolved.  You’re not looking to boil it hard at this point, that means the heat is too high, just a gentle heat until you can’t feel any crystals under your spatula against the base of the pan.

Jan 14 021

Add the cream, butter, vanilla extract and salt to the sugar mixture in the pan and turn the heat up to medium.  It may splutter a bit at you as it first goes in.

Jan 14 022Jan 14 023

Keep stirring until the butter has melted completely and the toffee is a smooth consistency.

Bring the mixture to the boil, , simmer for 3 minutes, again stirring fairly frequently, or until the temperature on the thermometer reads 112c.

Jan 14 025

Take it off the heat and give it a good stir in the pan.

Jan 14 059

Now, it can go straight into the chilled crust, but what I like to do, knowing that I would be disappointed if it’s too runny or if I’ve overdone it and I’m going to take someones teeth out I leave it to cool to room temperature in the pan.

Once it’s at room temp you can see how set it is.

Jan 14 058

If it’s just right warm it gently (easy to do because it’s still in the pan) without boiling it, stir it frequently just until it’s soft enough to transfer to the prepared crust.

Jan 14 061

If when you test it at room temp it’s too liquid, it needs to go back on the heat and simmered to reach 112c.  If it’s too chewy your rescue is again to warm gently but this time add more cream and butter (same amount again), taking care not to bring the mixture to the boil.

If you are making it without the sugar thermometer remember that the size of pan and the heat you cook it over are important, too big a pan or too much heat and the temperature of the toffee will be much hotter faster.  Remember a medium pan and a medium heat.

There’s a lot of instructions there for something that’s actually simple to do, but at least you have options!

So the toffee layer is now in the crust.  It needs to be chilled in the fridge for 30 minutes to 1 hr.  It’s happy to wait there until you’re ready for it.  Once chilled it’s time to get it out of the tin,  for the push pan you just set the base on top of a mug or something similar and push down the sides to separate the base from the sides.  Carefully slide a palette knife under the base of the crust to release it and transfer it to a serving plate,  a low sliding action works well!

Softly whip the double cream with the 2 tbsps icing sugar and set to one side.

Jan 14 066

Slice the bananas and arrange over the top of the toffee.  Add a double layer if you love banana! But reserve 2-3 slices for the top if you’re serving it shortly.  It’s not worth doing if you aren’t serving for a good few hours as the exposed banana will quickly go brown.

Jan 14 065

Add the whipped cream, I find it works well to add it all to the centre and then work it out to the edge of the crust with a palette knife.

Jan 14 067 Jan 14 068

Decorate the middle of the top with the reserved slices of banana and decorate with a scattering of grated chocolate.

Jan 14 069

Now enjoy!

Jan 14 078

Banoffee Pie

Ruth Clemens, Baker Extraordinaire

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Print Friendly, PDF & Email
This entry was posted in Banana, Caramel, Children, Kids, Pie, Treats. Bookmark the permalink.

20 Responses to Banoffee Pie

  1. Kate says:

    I made Banoffee over Christmas. I wanted an easy way to do the condensed milk thing and discovered that instead of boiling, you can put it in a slow cooker! I just covered it with water and left it cooking for 8 hours. I did top up once but I think I could have put more water in to start. Then I left it to cool. It was great because my kitchen didn’t get steamed up and there was less panic that the tin might explode.

  2. Mandy says:

    Hi Ruth, this looks gorgeous and can’t wait to make it. I would just like to ask though that if I make the toffee sauce from scratch ie: using the brown sugar etc any idea how long this would keep for?

    Many thanks

  3. Soraya says:

    Hello Ruth, I love caramel and love the idea of banoffee pie but I can’t eat bananas. Any ideas for a substitute? I tried strawberries once but was not convinced. Maybe hazelnuts for a topic vibe but not sure it would work. I need your genius! X

  4. Karrie says:

    A tip YOU will love Ruth. PROMISE it works. To stop bananas going brown place bananas still in their skins in bowl / saucepan and pour boiling water over to cover. Watch the skins go black then pour water away and plunge into cold water or under cold tap to cool quickly. Peel and the bananas will not go brown. Don’t know how it works but it seems as if all the black goes into the skin! (Best not to use over-ripe bananas though as if they are already going black or black in the centre it doesn’t work as well.) PLEASE try it. You will thank me, honest! PS I know it sounds weird 🙂

  5. This is excellent and I really appreciated all the options.

  6. Andrew Sceats says:

    Is there a good/interesting alternative to banana (the taste of which makes me gag) for this recipe?

  7. Gerryberry says:

    HI Ruth, Thank you so much for the lovely recipe, I have been waiting for your first post for 2014. Quick question, Is it possible for me to boil the can of condensed milk in the oven to make the caramel? Please do let me know as to how I am to go about it. Thanks in advance!!!!

    • I’m not sure how successful or safe it would be to do in the oven in the tin, although maybe you weren’t meaning that? I have tried unsuccessfully to heat the condensed milk in the oven to convert to caramel in a casserole type dish so I’m afraid I can’t give you any help with that one at the moment! xx

    • Elina says:

      Hi Gerryberry! I think it would work! I have used AGA cooker for that, I put the pan with water and the can of condensed milk (before I brought it to boil on the stove) in the oven with temperature 90C for around 3-4 hours and it worked out perfectly! I don’t know but could be shorter time in the oven also will do. Good luck!

  8. Lorna says:

    Oh this looks so delicious – the perfect weekend treat.

  9. Austin mahone says:

    Yum thanks kate

  10. Austin mahone says:

    Brilliant yum

  11. Pingback: Top 10 British Desserts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *